Attorney General Letitia James refiled a proposed motion for a temporary restraining order (TRO) in Manhattan Supreme Court on Friday, seeking to immediately prohibit Kalshi from offering sports, culture, election, and other contracts within New York.
The proposed TRO is not limited to contracts purchased by customers physically located in the state. The filing specifically reads “within or from New York or to persons in New York without being licensed by the New York State Gaming Commission.”
Daniel Wallach, a gaming attorney, warned in a post on X that it could have major implications for New York-based prediction market exchanges. Both Kalshi and Polymarket are headquartered in New York.
James’s proposed TRO also seeks to prohibit Kalshi from permitting anyone under 21 to purchase covered event contracts. Wallach said the provision is significant, given New York’s minimum age of 21 for legal sports betting.
Wallach also noted the proposed TRO targets advertising, marketing, and soliciting participation in covered event contracts. “It specifically references college campuses and university-owned newspapers, radio, and telecast,” he wrote.
Meanwhile, New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani took an opportunity to criticize prediction markets and sports-event contracts, although he confirmed he had never personally used Kalshi or Polymarket
Speaking at the New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday, Mamdani expressed his concern that expanding betting opportunities could have damaging consequences.
“It does degrade so much of life to make everything the subject of a bet,” the mayor said, according to The Hill.
Forty-three states oppose CFTC’s sports-contract rule
A bipartisan coalition of state attorneys general, co-led by Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, has called on federal regulators to withdraw a proposed rule intended to expand federal control over sports betting.
The coalition of 42 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia expressed their concern that sports-event contracts would undermine states’ authority to protect consumers.
The attorneys general filed a formal comment with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) challenging its attempt to classify sports-related event contacts as financial instruments known as “swaps.”
“The CFTC claims that four (Commodity Exchange Act) provisions include sports gambling event contracts as swaps. None does so,” the letter reads. “A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so.”
Wilson stressed that the agency doesn’t get to invent powers that Congress never gave it, as well as “ignore federal court decisions and bulldoze state consumer protections.
“If Congress wanted the commission running sports gambling, it would have said so, and headquartered it in Las Vegas,” he added.
The CFTC released the proposal on October 9, with the goal to expand the definition of swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) to include contracts tied to sports, politics, culture, and weather. The proposal notes these contracts are financial instruments and proposes to resolve any ambiguity regarding these contracts.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig believes these products are commodity derivatives squarely within the agency’s regulatory remit under the CEA and are within their exclusive jurisdiction.
In their comment letter, the coalition argues that prediction markets allow users to wager on sporting events much like traditional sportsbooks, but without the same state oversight. The proposed rule, they believe, could further open the door for these platforms to bypass licensing requirements, age restrictions, and protections against problem gambling.
The coalition also points to federal appellate court decisions rejecting the CFTC’s claimed authority over sports betting. The 43 attorneys general challenge the agency’s ability to adopt the rule with only one commissioner currently serving, arguing that it lacks the required quorum.
The letter warns that the proposal could encourage traditional sportsbooks to reorganize as prediction markets, effectively sidestepping state gambling laws and leaving consumers without established safeguards.
Wilson and along with the other state attorneys general urge the CFTC to withdraw the proposed rule and clarify that sports betting contracts are not financial swaps subject to its jurisdiction.
Fourth Circuit rules 2-1 in Maryland’s favor
A divided U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit sided with Maryland, denying Kalshi’s appeal of allowing gaming regulators to pursue enforcement actions against the prediction market operator for permitting users to purchase sports-event contracts without a license.
The 2-1 decision by the Richmond, Virginia-based Fourth Circuit in favor of the regulator was met with skepticism by Kalshi, which stated that “judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong.”
“This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets,” Kalshi said in a statement.
Such a split increases the chances that the U.S. Supreme Court could be forced to take up the issue. The Ninth and Sixth Circuit appeals courts unanimously ruled against Kalshi, while the Third Circuit in Appeal delivered Kalshi’s only win, ruling New Jersey gaming regulators could not ban sports-event contracts.
But unlike the company, Kalshi’s co-founder Tarek Mansour did not mention the split decision in a post on X, instead calling it a “big win for the industry.”
“The Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi’s favor,” Mansour said. “People use prediction markets because they’re more fair, transparent, and reward being right. Free markets work. We should keep them that way.”
“This is a big win for the industry and millions of users,” he added.
James Baker, acting director of the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Agency, said the state was currently evaluating next steps.
“The Maryland Lottery is pleased to see that the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the state’s ability to regulate what is clearly sports wagering,” Baker said in a statement.

