From promise to product: Retaining customers requires alignment between departments

Monday, July 28, 2025 9:00 PM
Photo:  Shutterstock
  • Commercial Casinos
  • Igaming
  • Sports Betting
  • Tribal Gaming
  • Hillary McAfee, Special to CDC Gaming

The gaming industry loves acquisition marketing like toddlers love glitter. It’s shiny, exciting, and absolutely everywhere.

Operators and suppliers pour budget into first-time deposit offers, onboarding flows, product launches, and flashy ad campaigns to capture attention. But without aligning that promise to the actual player or client experience, all we’re doing is paying for churn.

Here’s the truth: Acquisition is only as valuable as the retention it drives.

Why Alignment Matters in iGaming, Casino, and Supplier Marketing

Marketing is often the first touchpoint for players, casino partners, or operators evaluating your platform. It sets expectations. However, if those expectations don’t match what happens next, such as withdrawal timelines, platform reliability, or customer support, users don’t just bounce to another platform. They disengage. And in gaming, disengagement equals lost revenue.

Take funding player accounts. PayNearMe, a payments platform serving the gaming industry, conducted research revealing 29% of players reported problems funding accounts or withdrawing money.

So, if your campaign promises easy funding but your process takes three to five business days, the issue isn’t just disappointment. It’s broken trust.

The same applies to vendors. If your marketing promises seamless integrations, top-tier support, and flexible integrations, but clients experience delays and confusion during onboarding, the disconnect can impact retention and referrals.

How to Align Acquisition with Real Experience

  1. Only market what you can deliver
    Before launching a campaign or releasing new product messaging, ask yourself: Does this reflect the real experience users will have? If it doesn’t, pause. Short-term gains aren’t worth long-term credibility loss.
  2. Collaborate across departments
    For both operators and B2B suppliers, alignment requires regular communication between marketing, product, payments, compliance, and support. Misalignment between these groups results in mixed messages and unmet expectations.
  3. Let creative reflect the truth
    Your ads, demos, and promotions should look and feel like the experience they represent. Players and partners can tell when it’s just a pretty version of reality. Honesty builds trust. Fantasy creates churn.
  4. Think beyond the acquisition moment
    Acquisition is just the start. Use your early retention funnel — onboarding messages, support outreach, and educational content — to reinforce the value you promised. That’s what turns new users into loyal customers.

The Bottom Line for Operators, Suppliers, and Platforms

It’s not enough to win the first click. You have to deliver on it.

In an industry crowded with noise and competition, the brands that win will be the ones that tell the truth in their marketing and back it up in the product. That applies to every corner of the gaming world, from online casino and sportsbook platforms to in-person loyalty tech and B2B suppliers.

When marketing and operations are aligned, the result isn’t just higher conversion. It’s deeper trust, stronger retention, and more sustainable growth.

Because in gaming, credibility isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s everything.

Hillary McAfee is a contributor for CDC Gaming and an independent social media marketing consultant specializing in the gaming industry. With a keen eye for industry trends, she shares insights on marketing strategies and social innovation. You can connect with her at hillarymcafee@gmail.com or follow her latest content on LinkedIn. Hillary McAfee is a social media marketer and brand consultant.